Dave I read all your posts in some Ford forum about ur E4od in 2007. its funny this forum came up. I wanted to find you and ask how everything worked out. As I see you have it in now and put some miles on it. What is your MPG and how do you like it?
Yes, that would be me, didn't think there was that much interest in the swap since most guys seem to just bash the E4OD as unreliable. I went through a lot of trouble with my swap and it was basically all my own fault. But since it was the first time I had even seen the inside of an automatic transmission, I can't really complain. I learned a lot and now I can honestly say it was worth it. The C6 is a nice transmission for its simplicity, low cost, and durability, but I could never go back to one after having the 4 speed.
Even if I would have to rebuilt my transmission every 2 years I would still keep it. However, all the bugs have been worked out of it and the truck is simply a joy to drive now. At 70 MPH I basically have 2 top gears, one for towing 2300 RPM, and overdrive for cruising empty 1650 RPM.
Fuel economy did improve by about 3 MPG on average. Last summer with the spiking fuel prices, I was driving very gently and hypermiling some of the time. I have a thread titled "Hypermiler's Thread" on ford trucks.com where I document several trips where fuel mileage was between 18 and 22 MPG mostly at 70 MPH. I was able to touch 20 MPG on rare ocasions with the C6, but never one fillup after another like I can with the E4OD.
Its tough to reach 20 MPG in the winter though. Last fillup was 16.3 MPG again, mostly at 70 MPH.
One thing that you can never do with a C6 and overdrive unit, is get below 2000 RPM at the speeds I cruise at. Torque converter slip won't allow that, so in case anyone is wondering about using 3.08s and and a GV overdrive, don't bother. You will probably be dealing with a lot of TC slip that will negate much of the potential for fuel economy.