At the risk of pulling this thread further into the weeds...
What's your take on hybrids? Something more than batteries?
Batteries are a big part of it. From a financial perspective, it looks like battery replacement will cost $3K+, and could be purchased as often as every five years (OTOH, some have implied that they don't expect the car to outlast the battery
). From an environmental perspective, what sort of long-term environmental impact is there in disposing of the battery packs? Some have claimed that hybrid batteries can be disposed without harming the environment, but I have yet to see someone quantify the statement...whereas I have seen strong implications that getting rid of hybrid batteries has about as large of an adverse impact as running a conventional gas engine for the period of time the batteries are expected to last.
In addition, there's the accuracy of the fuel economy ratings. It is apparent that the hybrid does quite well from a fuel mileage standpoint in city driving or in stop-and-go freeway driving. However, fuel economy takes a serious nosedive on a long freeway trip...simply put, the batteries exhaust themselves and the engine starts doing all the work. You end up with a car that's getting mileage similar to a conventional gas car (and maybe even slightly worse, with the extra vehicle weight from the battery packs and whatnot), regardless of what the trip computer's telling you.
I had to admit that some of my issues are political as well. I live in an area where a LARGE amount of hybrids are being sold, and it's very clear that most of the people buying them are doing so as a social statement. I have a big issue with anyone with a self-righteous holier-than-thou attitude regardless of political viewpoint
and hybrid drivers are no exception. Actually, while I consider myself a bit of an environmentalist, I am so disgusted with the American environmentalist movement that I refuse to associate myself with it in any way shape or form, and the fact that they have jumped on the hybrid bandwagon really exacerbates my negative attitude towards both.
Lastly, as a biodiesel supporter
I feel that the hybrid movement is eclipsing the biodiesel movement, which is probably an active effort on their parts, since American environmentalists hate diesels so much and will say and do ANYTHING to keep them off the road
So, in conclusion, from what I've seen, read, experienced, etc. hybrids have a hidden cost (batteries) that people don't realize, both financially and environmentally. They also aren't as good on fuel as advertised unless you only drive in the city (I will give them this; the regenerative braking concept is a good idea), and the majority of the crowd that's buying them is doing so for the wrong reasons. I'm all for alternative energy
but, to be blunt, I think we're wasting resources on this concept when we should be putting those resources into biodiesel, ethanol, etc, PARTICULARLY considering that there are diesels out there already that do better on fuel than hybrids. Imagine what could be done if more attention was paid to diesels...
Here's a few articles to read...
http://www.liberator.net/articles/LiberatorMark/hybridvehicles.html
http://www.carpoint.com.au/car-news/DesktopDefault.aspx?tabID=500648&ArticleID=5487&R=ce5487
http://www.usatoday.com/money/autos/2004-06-10-diesel-vs-hybrid_x.htm
http://www.usatoday.com/money/autos/2004-06-11-diesel-hybrid-diary_x.htm