E pump b.s.

Who has has a mech lift pump fill the crankcase???

  • Never

    Votes: 17 85.0%
  • It was not catastrophic

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Lost an eng.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Garbage_Mechan

Garbage Mechanic
Joined
Jun 9, 2008
Posts
989
Reaction score
492
Location
Central Cal Foothills
One thing you can't do with a mechanical pump...

Bring the system up to pressure without cranking the engine over. (And over and over and ov.......)

THIS is the key reason for me. I have run into battery / starter issues before trying to recover from a minor fuel supply problem. The last time I was a ways from help when it stalled while off road. Grabbed air somehow and since it was essentially idling at the time (up a steep rough incline) it got pretty loaded with air. Even after cracking a few high pressure lines loose it just did start before the batteries died.
( Always keep a 5/8 wrench in the truck)
 

Cubey

Van dweller
Joined
Oct 18, 2017
Posts
4,128
Reaction score
1,618
Location
USA
THIS is the key reason for me. I have run into battery / starter issues before trying to recover from a minor fuel supply problem. The last time I was a ways from help when it stalled while off road. Grabbed air somehow and since it was essentially idling at the time (up a steep rough incline) it got pretty loaded with air. Even after cracking a few high pressure lines loose it just did start before the batteries died.
( Always keep a 5/8 wrench in the truck)

I carry an old Yamaha 500W generator with a built in 12v battery charger. So yeah, a gas powered battery charger. But I also have a smart battery charger that can be run from the generator so... it's kind of redundant. The generator's is a dumb charger.
 

dgr

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Posts
915
Reaction score
238
Location
sac town
I'll give you that, because I don't know any better. ;)

But we aren't running cummins. I was talking about our mechanical pump. :D
Haha

We're talking about their mechanical lift pump. 94-98 12V

I did find an article that states the efficiency is crap. Which I find interesting and germane to our fuel delivery.

http://www.torkteknology.com/technical-article-1-cummins-lift-pump/

Looks like they max output is 36 gph. HP is fuel limited. Stock 12V produces 235 HP. Why do we need so much volume to keep pressure to the IP above 0 PSI?
 

Thewespaul

Supporting Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Posts
8,796
Reaction score
8,059
Location
Bulverde, Texas
Haha

We're talking about their mechanical lift pump. 94-98 12V

I did find an article that states the efficiency is crap. Which I find interesting and germane to our fuel delivery.

http://www.torkteknology.com/technical-article-1-cummins-lift-pump/

Looks like they max output is 36 gph. HP is fuel limited. Stock 12V produces 235 HP. Why do we need so much volume to keep pressure to the IP above 0 PSI?

Inline pump is set timing, our pumps have a hydraulic advance circuit that takes fuel volume that the inline pump doesn’t have. On my 20hp test stand (2600lbs antique) the supply pump maxed out can supply 100 psi solid to a pretty hot p7100. On my 400cc db2, it was dropping from 100 psi to 40psi at high rpms, and it’s rated at 200gph.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dgr

dgr

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Posts
915
Reaction score
238
Location
sac town
Good stuff Wes. My understanding of what you posted is the advance is bypassing a ton of fuel to operate. Fuel supplied - advance bypass = hp potential. I want a centrifugal operated advance.

That guy's second page of his article goes into fuel flow as one of the reasons stock lift pumps have issues supplying enough fuel. Short version is it needs bigger fuel lines.

Who's going to pony up and buy one of the $700 aftermarket pumps? That and both tanks full would double the value of my truck LOL
 

raydav

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2006
Posts
408
Reaction score
143
Location
Apple Valley, CA
I currently have six vehicles that run. My wife's 73 Mach 1/460 is the only one that still has a mechanical fuel pump. I built it almost two decades ago and all I have done to it since is repaint it.

The 01 PSD and 65 Mustang run 60# EFI fuel systems. That leaves two carbureted and the IDI which are low pressure supply systems.

To construct, test and later troubleshoot a fuel supply system, it must move fuel. If the pump is engine driven mechanical, then the engine must be running to test the fuel system and there must be a functioning fuel supply system for the engine to be able to run. Catch 22.

As for how good a pump an IDI requires. I run pumps thru a three way switch so that I can have it run when there is engine oil pressure, always or never. At least twice I have driven off with the supply pump off. My van weighs 9K#. I drove 50 MPH, three miles, flat ground. The IP pulled fuel thru a Racor filter and the supply pump. Some day I might turn the supply pump off on a hill to see what happens.
 

Macrobb

Full Access Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2016
Posts
2,380
Reaction score
1,234
Location
North Idaho
As for how good a pump an IDI requires. I run pumps thru a three way switch so that I can have it run when there is engine oil pressure, always or never. At least twice I have driven off with the supply pump off. My van weighs 9K#. I drove 50 MPH, three miles, flat ground. The IP pulled fuel thru a Racor filter and the supply pump. Some day I might turn the supply pump off on a hill to see what happens.
Yeah, if there is no air in the lines, the filter isn't clogged and there is no leaks... IP will pull fuel just fine. But, you'll run a hair retarded due to the lower inlet pressure on the IP.
I recall doing that with a mechanical pump too... I had the lift pump off the motor but still hooked up via flexible lines to the filter; I think I was swapping a cam at the time.
I went to test it... fired it up, and noticed that the pump wasn't actually in place... <_<.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
91,328
Posts
1,130,426
Members
24,133
Latest member
Nanohawk

Members online

Top