Well I thought these all gear driven units just had a simple on or off switch to put them in gear or out of gear. These differ from the Gear Vendors because these are working on first gear from a dead stop. They are a positive gear engagement too. That small electric motor loads a spring. Then you lift off the throttle a tiny bit and it shifts quickly into gear either up or down. The Gv needs hydraulic pressure to shift and its a clutch engagement. Not gears. You have to be rolling around 20 mph to make the GV work and they wont work on the dead start like US Gear units will. Another selling point of the GV is if it breaks you can still run but not so with the US Gear units... Also Towcat has posted thet he has seen the GV units break so badly they stopped the trucks from moving down the road... Thats unusual....
FWIW, what towcat said about GV's breaking so badly as to stop trucks from moving altogether...I've heard that before as well. Actually, from what I gather, the only way a U.S. Gear unit is going to fail in a way to keep the truck off the road altogether is if the shift motor fails in mid-shift (or if it loses oil and seizes up, but that could easily happen to any gearbox).
As to the electrical parts...as I understand it, the shift motor on the Doug Nash/U.S. Gear units is a reverse-polarity setup. I could certainly be wrong, but from what I've researched and gathered, it sounds like the early units have microswitches in the motor assembly that cut 12 volt power to the motor when the shift is complete, and the later units have an electronic control box that automatically cuts power (either on a timer, or based on sensed current flow; I'm not certain). I have to say, though, that I would be happy with a definitive answer...I'm deathly afraid of burning out the motor on my unit when I first hook it up
IMHO the single biggest argument for the GV unit is that they're still sold and supported. Doug Nash/U.S. Gear unit owners are pretty much on their own at this point...to be completely honest, while I am committed to the Doug Nash unit now, if I knew then what I know now, I would have opted for a GV. But, it is what it is...