First post for me, Oilburners folks have helped a ton on my 1989 "revive"
I have a 89 with a manual and tracked down an issue with a bouncing tach this week. I have replaced the tach sensor before (2x actually, one aftermarket one had the wrong thread pitch, so I found a NOS), when I drug the truck off a farm 2 yrs ago there was no movement on the gauge. Put the NOS in and it worked great, till recently. Last week it would sporadically start bouncing, but more noticeably at idle. If i pressed the clutch in it would almost always go away. I figured it was a connection issue since it could be replicated, and banging on the dash would bring it back, until a couple days ago when it went radio silent. I cleaned the tach sensor on the IP housing (end is magnetic, have read that metal can accumulate, hopefully not), and cleaned connector above IP. No improvement when I drove it the next day. Next check was the gauge and that was the issue. Not the gauge itself, but the where the pins on the back of the gauge go into the instrument cluster. The spring connections where the male conductive ends of the gauge are held in by the cluster, one or more had lost tension (age, the suspension similar to a fork lift, improper repair? idk) but carefully bending the inner parts of those tabs back out to where they grab onto the stud connections of the gauge fixed my issue.
Could be a long shot, but maybe the module uses a common ground with the gauge? Worth a shot before you start buying parts. Attached a pic of the tabs after I bent them cleaned them up a touch. Also, pic of the truck