No it ain't - matter of fact I think this is the worst way one can go about making one pedal out of two. Reason - the butt weld! Just measured up my small truck, the distance between the center of the pad you step on and the center of the pin for the booster pushrod is right around 11", on the pics of the modded pedal it looks like the weld is about and inch away from the booster pushrod pin. During brake application the booster pushrod pin becomes a pivot support and this particular pedal becomes a cantilever with ratios of 1:11 (I'm well aware this ain't exactly scientific, tis just an approximation cause I don't seem to be able to find my speadsheet that can calculate everything properly a whole lot faster than my half-dead brain will) - last time I actually measured it I was able to put down about 170-175 lbs of pedal force during panic stop, which with our cantilever becomes around 1900 lbs shear force at a weld that is what, 1-3/8" wide wide and 3/8" thick. To put it bluntly, even if both pedal pieces were properly chamfered/bevelled to ensure good penetration, this is still a sh*tload of force to recon with... IMHO the person who built this pedal is a moron, and should have that contraption they created shoved up their ass as deep as it will go!
Riotwarrior, I'm sorry if I come out as an a-hole, but I call it how I see it - and what I see there is something very very unsafe! It ain't irreparable tho - if the geometry of this particular pedal works out for your hydro setup then I suggest that you take it in for fish-plating ASAP - in other words it needs a reinforcement plate welded to the passenger-side of the pedal arm from right around the main pivot at the top to several inches below the booster pushrod pin. Given the width and thickness of the pedal arm in that area, I'm thinking a piece of flat-stock that is 1" wide and at least 1/4" thick should work out pretty good for such reinforcement as it will allow for fillet welds on the long edges so there will be good penetration in both pieces being welded. Also, you may wanna take it to a different welder guy - see, the customer may always be right but often they're also uneducated (not an insult directed at you, just a general statement), and it's up to the fabricator to suggest modifications to the project at hand so the end result is still what the customer wants, but it also serves its intended purpose right - that welder guy you used forgot the last part of this, for what he gave you is what you wanted (two pedals made into one) but it's not what you should run as a major part of your vehicle's safety equipment.