If you are using the correct 2 piece seal people are talking about, that nick will not affect anything. With the two piece seal you actually put rtv over the nick and all around that shiny surface that the old seal ran on. I always get my seal from Autozone, they used to sell Timken. It's not cheap, it's been awhile but I want to say it's almost $40.00 for the seal. But it will not leak.