Robert, great to see you have your new tool! The way you have it put together in the last picture, is the corect way it should go. When I pulled my freeze plugs, the engine was out of the truck. I drilled a 1/2 in. hole in the plug, put a pointed heel bar in the drilled hole and poped the old plug out. After the block came back from the machine shop I cleaned the hole with a wire brush and brake clean, then I put a thin layer of permatex anaerobic gasket maker around the lip that the freeze plug rests on. Then I put the new freeze plug in the hole, hold it inplace with the outer piece of the tool, slide the inner shaft into the outer & thump it with your hammer , when the top of the inner tool stops after hitting the outer piece your home free! It won't let you dent the plug too much. Good luck mpa