The benefits to more oil are extended drain intervals, cooler running from the fins and cooler running generally due to a little more dwell time for the oil in the pan. The point about getting up to temp is well made but it's not much of an issue. I have one on my F150 and it knocked off about 15F in my tow test. The warmup time, something I have looked at, is not noticeably longer... at least not some much that I can say, "it takes X minutes longer." In theory, it's a concern. In practice... not so much for me. Is it worth the extra money? For most of us, I'd have to honestly say no... spend your money on a Magnefine! I do like the built in port for a temp sensor and the nice magnetic drain, but you can add these things to a stock pan fairly easily for next to no money. Enhanced filtration does more to extend my trans OCI than a few extra quarts of oil does. The extra oil capacity and cooling would likely be worth more to someone who worked their truck very hard. 15F is worth some money in that case.