The weird part is the nut was tight when I put the braces on like a year before that, so how did it get loose when the fan blade is not turning with respect to the water pump I have no idea...QUOTE]
I believe that the high compression of the IDIs shut them down hard and that's what makes the nut loosen. I do like the brackets as they do offer an added level of "fan coming off and lunching your radiator" protection.
That being said: to each his own, I'm going electric.