The important thing to remember is that in addition to cold cranking amps, there is also the issue of time. Batteries are rated in amp hours, so the larger batteries will be able to provide maximum current for a longer time, then a smaller battery. When it gets cold, the current available from a battery is always less, so the bigger the battery, the more likely it will be to deliver sufficient amperage when it's capacity is diminished. Guys like the group 31 batteries, because they pack a larger punch for a longer time, under more severe circumstances.