sle2115
NRA LIFE MEMBER
I've had both under my truck. It came with 3.55's and I swapped to 1 ton 4.10 axles. My truck ran good with both, but for my uses (hauling and pulling stuff) the 4.10's work great. Mileage definetely suffers on the highway, but I don't do that much anyway. I think 3.73's would be about the best compromise. When I had the 3.55's and hauled wood for the club, which is up a very steep grade, I thought I was going to have to shift into low range to make it. It actually just ran out of go, but never stopped going. I have the 4 speed as well. Since going to the 4.10's, I walk up the same hill hardly touching the throttle, just let it crawl along. Out on the highway, well, on the 65 MPH ones (read 70+ MPH) it really talks to you and LOVES it's fuel, but that's rare for me. I guess the thing you need to figure out is what the majority of your use will be and decide from there. I don't drive my truck everyday, or on the highway much, so it doesn't really bother me that it likes fuel because it seems like it would pull a house or two, which is what I need most.