The difference in a better quality return kit and IP and starter and gp's is for an Idi these repairs should be good for 5 years or more. I've sold lots of kits to people that go cheap and are unhappy. Just sayin
I overtightened that on my last starter and it spun as well. Would not crank over.. Spun it back and it worked for years
Fwiw I'm running a Powermaster now and very happy with the results.
Really? I actually tried that and it didn't work. Maybe I need to turn it a little further. I'll try it.