In our pan installation, there was just no reason to pull the motor, as the bottom of the engine was wide open. On repeated attempts, RTV just would not seal at the curve at the front main. It was POURING out in minutes. I understand that if you
HAVE to pull it because it is too huge of a hassle to do in the truck it makes sense to use RTV as they did from the factory. But IN the truck, with oil dripping down from the inside of the engine, it is awfully difficult to KEEP clean surfaces that you have properly prepared. We used a cork gasket, with both surfaces lightly coated with Permatex #2 (kind of like tar). Torqued all bolts non-consecutively, and it has not leaked a drop since. Granted, it has only been driven 800 miles since then, but that is 100 times more miles than we got from the RTV installation.