I know this doesn't really help... but.......
I have Weathertech Fitted Mats in the Front, and the Husky liner in the rear of my SuperCrew and am happy with the quality and fit of both.
The reason I have 2 different brands, when I bought the truck it had the Weathertechs in it and the factory carpet squares in the back. We have a liquidation store here locally (has a bunch of Amazon return type stuff) and happen to have one that fit my truck for cheep (like almost "stole" it cheep)..... and I would not hesitate to buy either brand. I really wish I would have spent the $300+ for the Weathertechs for my Excursion (the 3 sets basically cover 90% of the floor) because my tan carpet would be much more tan than dirty grungy "we have kids/grandkids" brown......